How to become an independent insurance agent

This post is part of a series sponsored by Darkhorse Insurance.

The insurance industry has grown rapidly in 2025, making it an ideal time to learn how to become an independent insurance agent. As consumer expectations and technological advances shape the industry, agents should have flexibility and autonomy. Getting rid of captivity and embracing being an independent insurance agent is no longer an option. This is a strategic move that can help you thrive in this new era.

What are the changes in the agency insurance industry in 2025?

The insurance industry will undergo a critical transformation in 2025, creating new opportunities and challenges for agents. Here are some of the key changes that drive the transition to independence:

• Digital conversion – Technology is reshaping how insurance is sold, managed and repaired. Now, it is expected that agents will adopt digital tools to simplify operations and enhance customer interaction. Independent agents are free to choose their tools and platforms, which can better utilize technology and remain competitive.
• Changes in consumer behavior – Modern customers need convenience, personalized solutions and the ability to compare policies of multiple carriers from the device. Captive agents, limited to products from one carrier, are often difficult to meet these requirements. However, independent agents can offer tailored solutions that align with evolving consumer expectations.
• The rise of non-attack models – Non-attribute insurance models are becoming more and more popular as agents seek flexibility and autonomy. Due to fewer restrictions, independent agents can diversify their product portfolio, work with multiple operators, and establish customized strategies for customers. This adaptability is the key to the competitive market in 2025.
• Regulatory changes – Many states are updating their insurance regulations to encourage transparency and competition. This reduces barriers to independent agents and makes it easier to work with multiple carriers or establish independent agencies. Captive agents may find that their roles become more restricted due to carrier-specific compliance.
• Competition directly to the consumer model increases – Direct-to-consumer (DTC) insurance platforms have become more common, putting pressure on agents to be different. Independent agents can leverage their ability to provide personalized advice and multiple carrier options to stand out in ways that the DTC platform cannot replicate.
• Focus on professional niche markets – Agents are increasingly dividing their niches in areas such as agriculture, cyber insurance or small business insurance. Independent agents can use a variety of operators and products that can serve these specialized markets compared to captive agents that are bound by single provider products.

Why switch?

Many insurance agents start their careers in captivity, working for agents representing only one carrier or a few selected carriers. Although the model provides some security and training, it also has significant limitations, especially in terms of choice and freedom. As the insurance landscape continues to shift in 2025, there are several reasons to consider getting rid of imprisonment and embracing independence.

1. More operator options – One of the most important benefits of becoming an independent insurance agent is the wider use of carriers. With non-attribute insurance, you can offer a variety of policies from multiple providers to tailor advice to your customers’ needs. This flexibility allows you to compete better in the market because you are not limited to products from one insurance company.
2. Higher commission potential – As an independent agent, you have better control over your revenue. Non-attribute insurance agents usually receive higher commission rates because they are not bound to a provider’s fixed structure. This increased income potential is a powerful driving force for those who want to take charge of their financial future.
3. Greater autonomy – When you get rid of the limitations of captive agent roles, you gain the ability to choose your own clients. You can also set your own goals and design a business plan that suits your lifestyle and desires. The flexibility and freedom to be an independent agent are unparalleled, especially when the industry adopts digital platforms and more distant job options.
4. Change consumer behavior – As technology continues to reshape the way customers interact with insurance, consumer expectations have changed. Now consumers need convenience, personalized services and the ability to compare multiple options in one place. By becoming an independent insurance agent, you will have a better location to meet these needs and provide flexibility and tailor-made solutions to your customers desire.

How to become an independent insurance agent In 2025

The transition from captive to independent insurance agent roles may seem daunting, but with the right approach, you can make the transition smoothly and successfully. Here is a step-by-step guide on how to become an independent insurance agent this year:

1. Assess your current situation – It is crucial to evaluate your current position before making any changes. Take a look at your experience, current customer base, and knowledge about the insurance industry. Are you willing to work independently? Do you have a strong sales pipeline or a relationship that may follow your customers? Knowing your location will help you plan your transition effectively.
2. Research on independent insurance opportunities – There are several ways to become an agent for non-captive insurance. You can join an existing independent agency, start your own independent insurance company, or work with a network or franchise. Studying the pros and cons of each option can help you find the best suited needs and goals for you.
3. Obtain the necessary licenses and certificates – Depending on your location and the type of policy you plan to sell, you may need an additional insurance license or certification to operate as an independent agent. Be sure to contact the state’s insurance regulator to ensure you meet all legal requirements before you leap.
4. Choose your carrier wisely – As an independent insurance agent, you will be free to work with a variety of carriers. It is important to choose a partnership that aligns with your niche or target market. Research different insurance companies to find people with competitive reputations, people with strong support for independent agents.
5. Implement the correct tool – Operating a successful independent insurance agent requires a solid foundation of tools and resources. An essential component is an insurance agency management system that simplifies customer communications, policy management and tracking.
6. Promote yourself effectively – As an independent agent, you need to stand out in a highly competitive market. Leverage digital marketing tools to create a user-friendly website and leverage social media to build your brand. Word of mouth and recommendation are powerful tools, but actively promoting your services will help you attract new customers and build a reputation in the industry.

Become a key advantage Non-capturing insurance agent

• Freedom and flexibility: Control your schedule and work-life balance.
• Increased income potential: Provide more insurance products and get higher commissions.
• Diverse career opportunities: Work with various carriers and clients and pursue different wall niches.
• Customer-centric service: Provide tailored solutions to meet the unique needs of each customer.

Overcome common challenges

While transitioning to an independent insurance agent may be rewarding, it does present challenges. Some common obstacles that insurance agents face when they go from captive to non-aggressive roles include:

• Lack of brand recognition: As an independent agent, you may not have the recognition or support you have obtained when working in a major insurance company. Overcoming this requires solid branding, marketing and building a loyal customer base.
• Create new relationships: Transferring from captive roles means you need to establish new relationships with multiple carriers and clients. Building trust and reputation takes time, but it is a critical part of the process.

Disconnect and build your independent insurance career

2025 is a year to control one’s career and get rid of the limitations of the role of a captive insurance agent. Transitioning to an independent agent gives you the freedom, flexibility and the potential to make money to grow your business according to your terms. If you are interested in learning more about switching, discover more about becoming a Darkhorse agent and start your journey toward greater independence today.

theme
mechanism