In that moment, you open the salary and something looks…but good. Maybe your compensation exceeds the bonus or reward strike you are not told. You may feel suspicious, but don’t worry. Then, just when you use the money or budget it for your month, your employer comes back and says it’s a mistake they want to get it back.
If you find yourself in this situation, you are not alone. Overpayment errors occur more frequently than you think, and many employees are unsure what rights they have or how to deal with without compromising their job security or financial stability.
Can employers really ask for the money?
Legally, yes. In most states, if your employer even surpasses you by their own mistakes, they have their own right to claim a refund. This is called “payback” and is usually allowed under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).
But this does not mean that the process is always fair, direct or non-negotiable. Your employer has to follow some rules and you have a choice, especially if repayment is a one-time problem that can lead to your hardship.
How to repay should Work
The most important thing to know is that your employer can’t just pull out money from your next salary without your permission, at least not in most states. You must notify you of overpayment notice and many states require your written consent to recover any salary deductions for the excess payment amount.
If your company tries to deduct it without notifying you or giving you a chance to raise an objection, it could be a violation of the state wage law. In some cases, especially in union jobs or roles covered by a specific employment contract, automatic deductions may be prohibited.
You are also entitled to claim repayment of the plan. Employers may be willing to extend repayments over several salary periods, or if the repayment is paid immediately puts you at financial risk.
What if you have already spent money?
This is the tricky place. If you have used these funds on rent, bills, or daily expenses, repayment may be impossible. Unfortunately, hardship alone doesn’t relieve you of your responsibility, but it does strengthen your case of negotiating repayments.
In some cases, especially if overpayment is caused by negligence by the employer or payments not noticed for several months, you may have legal reasons to object to full repayment. This varies from state to state, but when the error is serious, the court occasionally supports the staff, and there is no realistic way for workers to know they are being paid.
When you may not have to pay it back
If overpayment is secondary and your contract or employee manual does not explicitly allow for wage deductions, you may be able to fight it. Also, if errors are found long after the facts occur, some states have time limits on the time the employer must ask for repayment.
Additionally, if a company goes out of business, or is misclassified in a way that leads to the wrong way, your liability may change. If you are asked to repay a large amount and feel that your goals or pressures are unfair, it is worth contacting an employment lawyer or a labor rights organization.
What should you do immediately
First, don’t panic. Do not verbally agree to anything or sign any document without reading it seriously. Detailed breakdown of the multi-payment, including payroll, payroll log and tax adjustments.
Secondly, communicate in writing. Whether you are negotiating a repayment or a disputed amount, you must keep your paper trail. Avoid discussing issues on the phone or with HR at will. Formalize your response and keep a copy of everything.
And if you feel something is wrong, whether you are threatened with injustice, forced to repay without notice, or if you think math is wrong, get a second opinion from an employment lawyer.
Employers make mistakes, but you don’t have to pay alone
If an error occurs, the salary department cannot be exempted from human error. But that doesn’t mean you should be financially penalized without recourse. Employers are responsible for maintaining accurate wage records and if they don’t, they also assume some responsibility to clear the chaos in a way that doesn’t undermine the financial situation of their employees.
It’s not about getting rid of what you don’t have correctly. It’s about protecting yourself from unfair practices, sudden hardships and assumptions that you just “find it”.
Have you ever been paid for your job and asked to return it to you? How did you deal with it – if it happened to you, would you fight?
Read more:
Forgot free snacks: 7 benefits staff are begging
Free Work: 6 types of employers to make you work for free (legal)
Riley is an Arizona native with over nine years of writing experience. From personal finance to travel to digital marketing to pop culture, she wrote everything in the sun. When she is not writing, she will spend time outside, reading or embracing two corgis.
